Does paying more for GPT-6.2 Astra buy you a better answer, or can Sol handle the same work? We gave both models four identical tasks covering circuit reading, Python repair, experiment analysis and a customer support reply.
The results were close, but a small instruction exposed a difference. In this article, we compare their answers, accuracy and API pricing to see where Astra earns its premium and where Sol holds its own.
TLDR: Sol matched Astra on the substantive checks and has one-quarter the API token rates; Astra followed the coding brief more closely.

What differs before you start
OpenAI positions GPT-6.2 Astra for demanding professional projects and GPT-6.2 Sol for everyday work. Both accept text and images and produce text, with a 1,050,000-token context window and up to 128,000 output tokens. Browsing, reading files and producing artifacts also depend on the tools around the model. A shared context limit doesn't imply equal performance on every document.
| Standard API rate per million tokens | GPT-6.2 Astra | GPT-6.2 Sol |
|---|---|---|
| Uncached input | $8 | $2 |
| Cached input | $0.40 | $0.10 |
| Output | $40 | $10 |
These are short-context Standard rates. Requests above 272,000 input tokens attract higher full-request rates; speed tiers and tools can also change costs. Work and Codex subscription usage is separate from API billing. We did not measure tokens, latency or the price of our sessions.

To repeat the setup, start a fresh Work chat, open the model selector, choose the exact 6.2 model and verify Ultra before submitting. The models are available through eligible Work and Codex plans and the API, subject to rollout and workspace permissions. Their Work rollout does not put the same choices into regular Chat.
The circuit and Python tests reuse the original Astra review runs. The CSV and support tests reuse the original Sol review runs. We then ran the identical prompt and input on the other model, using the first completed answer in each fresh chat. That gives four paired tasks, rather than comparing unrelated examples from two reviews. Calculation tools were allowed for the CSV; the other paired prompts prohibited tools or supplied all the required facts.
The same principle matters in our earlier GPT-6.1 Terra vs Sol comparison: compare matching inputs, then check the result rather than the confidence of the answer.
Circuit reading where two currents move in opposite directions
This task starts with an image attachment. R1 sits in series with a parallel pair. Disconnecting R3 increases the overall resistance, but it also changes the voltage available to R2. Simply saying that every current falls would miss the important relationship.

Prompt
Read the attached circuit diagram using ideal resistors and an ideal 12 V source. First identify which resistors are in series and parallel. Then give a compact table with equivalent resistance, total current, voltage across the parallel branch, and the currents through R2 and R3. Round to three decimals and include units. Finally, disconnect R3 only: calculate the new total current and R2 current, and explain whether each rises or falls. Show enough arithmetic to check the result. Keep the whole response under 160 words. Use only the image and basic circuit laws; do not browse or use tools. Keep the output anonymous: no personal names, organisations, account details, contact information, personal references or signature.
GPT 6.2 Astra:

GPT 6.2 Sol:

Both read the topology correctly, matched all five requested numerical results to three decimals and handled the disconnection. The useful check is the direction of change: total current falls to 1.714 A, while R2 current rises to that same value. We verified the circuit with exact fraction arithmetic. Neither answer needs a correction on the specified ideal circuit; this task supplies no reason to pay more for Astra.
Python repair where the algorithms tie and the format slips
The attached function sorts the caller’s list in place and can shrink a merged interval when it encounters a nested one. The repair must keep the furthest covered endpoint, reject malformed inputs and preserve the original list.
def covered_minutes(spans):
spans.sort()
if not spans:
return 0
start, end = spans[0]
total = 0
for next_start, next_end in spans[1:]:
if next_start <= end:
end = next_end
else:
total += end - start
start, end = next_start, next_end
return total + end - start
Prompt
Fix
covered_minutesin the attached Python file. It must return the union length of half-open integer intervals, so overlaps aren't counted twice. Ignore zero-length intervals. Accept negative endpoints. Reject reversed intervals, malformed pairs and non-integer endpoints (including booleans) with ValueError. Don't mutate the input or any pair inside it. Use only the standard library and O(n log n) time. Return one complete replacement function and five short asserts, including a nested interval and an immutability check. Keep the code under 45 lines. Don't browse or run tools. Keep the answer anonymous: no names, account details, organisations or signatures.
GPT 6.2 Astra:

GPT 6.2 Sol:

Both functions passed their five supplied assertion statements and 11,736 independent cases: exhaustive small interval lists, randomized mixed lists and tuples, and invalid inputs. Neither mutated the inputs. Sorting followed by a merge also met the requested O(n log n) design.
Astra stayed below the line limit. Sol returned exactly 45 original code lines, including blank lines, so it missed the strict instruction to stay under 45. Its extra validation loop was useful, but the brief still needed a trim. That's a narrow format advantage for Astra, not evidence that Sol's algorithm is worse or that either model will handle a repository change equally well.
A rollout whose aggregate rate points the wrong way
The CSV has five rows, including a duplicate R4 export. More importantly, the variant receives a much larger share of desktop visitors, and desktop converts better in both groups. The complete input is small enough to inspect:
| row_id | arm | device | visitors | conversions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | control | desktop | 1000 | 90 |
| R2 | control | mobile | 1000 | 20 |
| R3 | variant | desktop | 10000 | 800 |
| R4 | variant | mobile | 100 | 1 |
| R4 | variant | mobile | 100 | 1 |
Prompt
Read the attached CSV as a file. Duplicate row_id values are repeated exports of the same record; count each ID once. Compare control and variant conversion rates overall and separately for desktop and mobile. Report visitors, conversions and rates, plus the variant's overall percentage-point change. Would you roll out the variant based on this result? Explain the traffic-mix issue and one useful next check. Don't invent statistical significance. Use a calculation tool if useful. Keep the answer under 180 words. Keep it anonymous: no personal names, account details, organisations or signatures.
GPT 6.2 Astra:

Astra supplied a useful extra check: applying the control's 50/50 device mix to the variant's observed device rates gives 4.50%, one point below control. We verified that calculation independently. It describes a standardized comparison, not a measured result from a newly balanced experiment.
GPT 6.2 Sol:

Sol gave the same correct rates and hold decision, then recommended checking assignment logs against the intended device split. Both removed the duplicate, calculated the 2.43 percentage-point overall uplift and caught the one-point decline within each device group. Neither invented statistical significance. Astra added a helpful calculation; Sol still answered the complete rollout question.
A support reply that asks without promising an outcome
The customer wants two things today: a refund and a missing project restored. The policy permits review under specific conditions and says support cannot restore files. The model needs to sound helpful while keeping those limits intact.
Prompt
Write a warm, direct reply of 70–100 words to this customer. Policy: a refund may be requested within 14 days of purchase if usage is under two hours. A missing receipt doesn't automatically block review; support can search using the purchase email address and approximate payment date. Refunds aren't guaranteed. Support cannot delete or restore the customer's files. No action has been taken yet. Customer: 'The app crashed and my project disappeared. I bought it about two weeks ago and used it for maybe 90 minutes. I lost the receipt. Please refund me and recover my files today.' Ask for the minimum information needed to check eligibility. Don't invent a fix, promise a refund, or claim anything has been processed. After the reply, add one sentence identifying the unresolved eligibility detail. Keep everything anonymous: no names, account details, organisations or signature.
GPT 6.2 Astra:

GPT 6.2 Sol:

Astra's customer reply used 87 words; Sol's used 77, followed by the requested separate eligibility sentence in each case. Both asked for the purchase email address and approximate payment date, allowed purchase lookup without a receipt and avoided promising a refund or file restoration. Both identified the unconfirmed purchase date as the remaining eligibility issue at the reported usage. These are usable drafts for the supplied policy. The policy handling was a tie.
Why the launch coding headline needs its effort setting

The launch says Sol comes within half a point of Astra on FrontierCode 2.0 at Max. The published values are 44.2% for Astra and 43.8% for Sol. At High, the chart reports 43.6% and 39.7% respectively. A close Max result should not be presented as the High gap.

FrontierCode evaluates changes to real codebases against maintainer standards. Our interval function is a much smaller job, so its behavioral tie can coexist with a benchmark gap. The chart's costs belong to those evaluation runs, not our chats, and do not establish a saving on your project.
Conclusion
Start with Sol for work like these four tasks. It reached the correct substantive answers at lower published token rates; its one-line format miss is easy to identify and correct. Astra's standardized-rate calculation made the data answer more informative, but Sol still gave the right decision and next check.
Astra becomes worth testing when the job gets longer, has several dependent steps or demands a deliverable that Sol keeps getting wrong. Broader professional-work evaluations give a reason to try that comparison; they do not guarantee the result. Keep the same input, define what a usable output must do, and compare the correction burden. That is a better basis for choosing than upgrading every routine request because Astra is the flagship.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which model won the four paired tests?
Both passed the substantive checks. Astra followed the coding line limit; Sol missed it by one line.
Were both models tested at Ultra?
Yes. Every paired run used Ultra effort, matching prompts and inputs, a fresh Work chat and the first completed answer.
Is Sol four times cheaper?
Its Standard token rates are one quarter of Astra's. Completed-task cost varies with tokens, tools, speed tiers and retries.
Does the Max coding result apply to High?
No. The published FrontierCode gap differs by effort setting; the half-point launch comparison uses Max.